Op-ed: Lindsey Graham's finest hour

Profile photo of Peter Heck
Peter Heck
Image for article: Op-ed: Lindsey Graham's finest hour

Every public life is eventually distilled into a handful of defining moments.

Most speeches are forgotten almost as soon as they're delivered, and most political victories fade quickly into the ether of history.

But usually on at least one or two occasions, circumstances converge in such a way that a moment comes to define an entire career.

For the late Senator Lindsey Graham, that moment came on September 27, 2018, during the Senate Judiciary Committee hearings for Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh.

By that point, the confirmation process had become something few Americans had ever witnessed. Scurrilous allegations of sexual assault dating back more than three decades had overtaken the hearings, and the nation found itself bitterly divided over whether the proceedings represented a legitimate search for truth or a coordinated political railroading constructed from whole cloth to derail Kavanaugh's nomination.

Then Graham took the microphone.

What followed wasn't a carefully measured floor speech crafted to satisfy consultants or generate favorable headlines. It was the visceral reaction of a man who believed the institution he loved had abandoned even the appearance of fairness.

Looking directly at his Democratic colleagues, Graham unleashed:

Embedded content hidden

Subscribe to view the full article, including all images, videos, and social media embeds.

If you wanted an FBI investigation, you could have come to us. What you want to do is destroy this guy's life, hold this seat open, and hope you win in 2020 ... This is the most unethical sham since I've been in politics

...

Boy, y'all want power. God, I hope you never get it. I hope the American people can see through this sham.

Graham rightly recognized that something unseemly was unfolding before the country. The confirmation process had ceased to be about weighing evidence fairly and had become an exercise in political power where the process itself served as the punishment.

That conviction explains why his speech continues to resonate years later. Graham wasn't merely defending Brett Kavanaugh. He was defending the broader principle that accusations deserve to be investigated fairly, that due process matters, and that political ambition must never become an excuse for abandoning either.

Millions of Americans recognized exactly what he was describing.

They had watched allegations withheld for weeks, anonymous accusations emerge without corroboration, and a confirmation hearing gradually transform into little more than a unjustified and unjustifiable public shaming. Graham simply articulated what any fair minded person witnessing the spectacle in real time wanted to say.

As a Christian, it was a particularly meaningful moment. The biblical concern with justice extends beyond arriving at a correct verdict. Scripture repeatedly insists that justice also requires honest procedures, impartial judgment, credible witnesses, and fairness toward the accused.

"You shall not pervert justice," Moses commanded Israel (Deuteronomy 16:19), while Proverbs reminds us that "the one who states his case first seems right, until the other comes and examines him" (Proverbs 18:17).

Those legal principles reflect the character of a God who loves truth and hates false witness.

Lindsey Graham's career, like that of every long-serving politician, contained moments supporters applauded and moments they questioned. Conservatives frequently found themselves frustrated with his shifting positions, while progressives often opposed his hawkish foreign policy that envisioned the United States as the overseer of international affairs. Every public servant leaves behind a complicated record.

Even so, I suspect history will remember those few minutes during the Kavanaugh hearings more vividly than almost anything else he accomplished in public office.

For a brief moment, Graham stopped calculating political consequences and spoke with the unmistakable conviction of someone who believed an innocent man's life was being destroyed in pursuit of power.

It was the finest moment of his career.

Enjoying this article? Subscribe for full access.

Subscribers see every embed, image, and video inline — plus comments and our fully-featured social platform.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Not the Bee or any of its affiliates.