Nashville teachers say district is penalizing them for not fabricating grades

Profile photo of Harris Rigby
Harris Rigby
Image for article: Nashville teachers say district is penalizing them for not fabricating grades

Nashville, which I'm sure has a tremendous graduation rate, is in the headlines after multiple teachers who stood up to the school board have been reprimanded for not skewing grades to help pass students along.

Listen to this August 11 testimony from Samira Hardcastle, an award-winning art teacher at John F. Kennedy Middle School and a Blue Ribbon Teacher for the 2025-2026 school year:

One momma harassed the school district until they gave her baby a passing grade, and it got so bad that this award-winning teacher resigned from her job.

The news reports that behavioral issues are down, they are not. We are simply banned from reporting them, forcing us to keep disruptive students in the classroom. Statistics are being skewed to protect the district, not our children.

Our children cannot read or write. They cannot do basic math.

This is happening all over the nation. Teachers are being pressured into giving kids passing grades because it makes the schools look better (a win for administrators who want more federal tax dollars) and it makes parents happy.

Consider this 2018 story from Florida that is going viral again this week as well:

Meanwhile, in many major American cities, most children cannot read or do math at grade level and literacy is dropping off a cliff.

Nashville, despite being in a conservative state, is suffering from the same problems. Public education has become a cash cow and a money/credential laundering operation that allows schools to be run like a literal mafia.

This local news report covers both Hardcastle and fellow teacher Diana Wills, who says she was suspended for failing students without informing parents. 👇

They suspended a teacher for not telling parents about failing grades, and then told her that she had to give the students passing grades because of it.

How many school districts across the United States are run this way?


Watch our latest video 👇

Keep up with our latest videos — Subscribe to our YouTube channel!